VOLUME 114, ISSUE 3, P535-544
Stephanie Cheung, B.Sc., Philip Xie, B.Sc., Alessandra Parrella, M.Sc., Derek Keating, B.A., Zev Rosenwaks, M.D., Gianpiero D. Palermo, M.D., Ph.D.
To identify and treat the gamete responsible for complete fertilization failure with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) using a newly proposed assisted gamete treatment (AGT).
Prospective cohort study.
Center for reproductive medicine.
One-hundred and fourteen couples with an adequate number of spermatozoa for ICSI and a fertilization rate of ≤10%, after controlling for maternal age.
Couples with an oocyte-related oocyte activation deficiency (OAD) underwent a subsequent cycle with a modified superovulation protocol; couples with sperm-related OAD had an additional genetic and epigenetic assessment to identify mutations and expression levels of the corresponding genes.
Main Outcome Measure(s)
Treatment cycle outcome for couples undergoing ICSI with either a modified superovulation protocol or AGT compared with their historical cycle.
A total of 114 couples matched the inclusion criteria, representing approximately 1.3% of the total ICSI cycles performed at our center, with age-matched controls. Fifty-two couples were confirmed negative for sperm-related OAD by the phospholipase Cζ (PLCζ) assay, indicating oocyte-related factors in their failed fertilization cycles. Couples were treated by one of two AGT protocols, AGT-initial or AGT-revised, in a subsequent attempt that was compared with their historical cycle. Subsequent ICSI cycles with a tailored superovulation protocol yielded significantly higher fertilization (59.0% vs. 2.1%) and clinical pregnancy (28.6% vs. 0) rates. In 24 couples (mean ± standard deviation: maternal age, 35.6 ± 5 years; paternal age, 39.8 ± 6 years) sperm-related OAD was confirmed; in four men, a deletion on the PLCZ1 gene was identified. Additional mutations were also identified of genes supporting spermiogenesis and embryo development (PIWIL1, BSX, NLRP5) and gene deletions confirming a complete absence of the subacrosomal perinuclear theca (PICK1, SPATA16, DPY19L). Subsequent AGT treatment provided higher fertilization (42.1%) and clinical pregnancy (36% vs. 0%) rates for couples with a history of impaired (9.1%) fertilization. A comparison of the two AGT protocols, AGT-initial or AGT-revised, revealed that the latter yielded even more favorable fertilization (37.6% vs. 45.9%) and clinical pregnancy (21.1% vs. 83.3%) rates.
In couples with an oocyte-related OAD, tailoring the superovulation protocol resulted in successful fertilization, term pregnancies, and deliveries. In couples with a sperm-related OAD as determined by PLCζ assay, mouse oocyte activation test, and the assessment of gene mutations and function, AGT was successful. The AGT-revised protocol yielded an even higher fertilization rate than the AGT-initial protocol, resulting in the birth of healthy offspring in all couples who achieved a clinical pregnancy.