Home sperm testing device versus laboratory sperm quality analyzer: comparison of motile sperm concentration
YO Home Sperm Test is a user-friendly, accurate device for screening semen samples at home.
Volume 110, Issue 7, Pages 1277–1284
Ashok Agarwal, Ph.D., Manesh Kumar Panner Selvam, Ph.D., Rakesh Sharma, Ph.D., Kruyanshi Master, M.Sc., Aditi Sharma, M.Sc., Sajal Gupta, M.D., Ralf Henkel, Ph.D.
To test the ability of the smartphone-based YO Home Sperm Test to accurately and precisely measure motile sperm concentration (MSC) versus the SQA-Vision, an automated laboratory semen analyzer.
MSC compared for the YO device on Galaxy and iPhone smartphones versus the SQA-Vision in a double-blind manner.
Academic medical center.
Donor semen samples from 24 men in 144 aliquots.
Main Outcome Measure(s)
Accuracy, precision, and agreement assessed between the YO device and the SQA-Vision for MSC results.
The YO device demonstrated good correlation and good to moderate agreement with the SQA-Vision for MSC results up to a range of 94 × 106/mL with Pearson and concordance correlation coefficient above 0.92. The YO also showed a very high level of accuracy (97.8%) with positive and negative percent agreement above 94%. The difference in coefficient of variation between the YO and the SQA-Vision was low (between 9.4% and 11.2%) and not statistically significant. The precision among the YO phone devices was lower (16.0%) than the manufacturer's claim of ≤20%.
The smartphone-based device has a high level of accuracy and precision when compared with the SQA-Vision. It can detect samples with abnormally “low” MSC (below 6 × 106/mL cutoff), which supports its use as an effective home sperm test for screening “low” and “moderate/normal” MSC cases. In addition, the device effectively identifies varying levels of normal MSC in a precise manner over a wide range of normal MSC. Thus, the YO Score can improve patient satisfaction and empowerment.